When certifying CMM accuracy manufacturers had employed the VDI-VDE 2617 specification
which provides for a 95% confidence interval and evaluates linear accuracy specified
as U1 and volumetric accuracy specified as U3. In each case the specification provided
a 95% confidence level, which means 5% of the observations, could be excluded from
the testing data. This means "flyers" are tossed and effectively allowed machine accuracy
statements to report better accuracy than could actually be achieved.
The ISO 10360-2 specifications
changed all of this recognizing that in practical every day measurement the CMM user
does not have the luxury of excluding "flyers" and generally users do not even know
when flyers are observed. As such the ISO specification requires 100% of all observations
to be included in the evaluation of the CMM performance.
Under ISO 10360-2, the
machine is evaluated in at least 3 areas of its measuring volume.
MPEE is Volumetric
Length Uncertainty and utilizes calibrated gage blocks. Ball bars are not
used as their length is arbitrary and only the spheres can be calibrated. (B89 Standard)
Moreover, the measurement of a sphere employs many points to resolve the center which
does not represent practical measurement.
In
practical CMM measurement, point data is taken as required for the respective part
feature with the expectation that each point is accurate. There is no luxury to measure
multiple points and resolve (1) one point as that to be used in the part feature calculation.
Under ISO 10360-2 discrete
single points are measured bi-directionally to evaluate length and the MPEE value
reports the range of measurements from 7 different positions with 5 different gage
lengths, repeated 3 times. All 105 measurements with their deviation from certified
lengths are considered and are provided as the Uncertainty
of Measured Length (MPEE).
The other ISO
10360-2 evaluation for Touch probe CMMs is MPEP which
represents Probing Uncertainty.
The machine measures 25 discrete points that are evaluated as 25 individual radii.
The range of radii variation, min to max, is the MPEP value.
The other important ISO
10360-2 metric applicable to Scanning CMMs is MPETHP and
is similar to MPEP however
it is achieved by full contact scanning of 4 lines, of which, only one can be a full
360 degree equatorial scan. This evaluation comes from the ISO 10360-4 specification.
As above the points within each scan are treated as radii and the range of radii deviation,
min to max, is reported as MPETHP.